PD-disagg docs: annotated corrections for e13391e contamination

Adds dated, non-destructive correction notes to the contaminated PD-vs-colo
artifacts after the producer-eviction bug (`evict_blocks(sent_block_ids)` on
`finished_sending`, deployed over the "fresh" pip vLLM by
`scripts/deploy_vllm_patches.sh`) was found and gated behind
`VLLM_EVICT_SENT_BLOCKS` (default off).

  PD_DISAGG_RESULTS.md  top CORRECTION banner + §6 RETRACTED marker.
                        §6 (session-affinity hot-pin) was an `e13391e`
                        artifact under controlled concurrency; §3 RR, §4
                        TPOT win, §5 D-pool ceiling, §5.1 consumer crash
                        stand.
  RESULTS_SUMMARY.md    §4 confirm+refine note: clean ablation confirms
                        the D-pool capacity thesis and adds regime-
                        dependence.
  pd_separation_analysis.md  scoped caution: thesis confirmed; flags
                        only reuse-dependent figures for cross-check
                        (this study used a different stack).
  figs/mb5/CORRECTION.md  flags mb5_producer_hotspot.png as retracted;
                        §3 RR and §5 D-pool figures stand.
This commit is contained in:
2026-05-31 20:14:14 +08:00
parent 0b180c191e
commit a2111b6e18
4 changed files with 101 additions and 0 deletions

View File

@@ -97,6 +97,18 @@ dash1 GPU 0 单 instance无 kv_connectorchunked-prefill 默认开启,
- MB1 + MB2 的合计 cost-benefit phase isolation 维度上 PD-disagg 是赢的**但这件事被容量天花板压倒**。
- Paper §3.2 论证应该聚焦"D 池装不下"MB1/MB2 数据用作 supporting contextper-request transfer charge 量化phase isolation benefit 量化而不是 main argument
> ✅ **2026-05-30 更新 — 干净栈三轴 ablation 证实本节、并加 regime 细化。**
> 本节的容量论点D 池容量天花板 / decode 减半)在修复 `e13391e` 污染后的 clean stack
> 上**得到确认**concurrency 轴 N=64 时 PD 倾覆,**producer APC 从 71% 崩到 1.4%、TPS 30%**
> 而 colo 线性 scaleFig 3。**细化**PD 并非"在 agentic 上一律失败"——它在
> *低负载 / decode-heavy / 低复用* 区间**赢** colo真正失败的是 agentic corner高复用 +
> 短输出 + 大上下文 + 高并发)——静态 P:D split 无法同时给出复用所需的 producer 容量
> *和* decode 容量,而 colo 的弹性池两者兼得。
> **另注**:旧 MB5 文档(`PD_DISAGG_RESULTS.md` §6"session-affinity 救不了 PD / PD 复用=0%"
> 的结论是 `e13391e`producer 每次 KV 传输后 evict prefix的**污染产物,已撤回**
> 干净栈上 session 路由的 producer APC 与 colo 持平7182%)。
> 图:[`figs/mb5_pd_ablation/`](figs/mb5_pd_ablation/)。
## 5. EAR 设计的实证状态§4
| Pillar | 已实证 | 待实证 |