After the critic-agent audit, V2_DEEP_ANALYSIS had drifted into an
audit-grade "5 wins / 1 loss / 3 draws" framing that mistook KVC's
deliberate design motifs (cache concentration via session affinity;
prefill-GPU idle as TTFT-stability trade-off) for "comparison
unfairness." This commit corrects the framing back to a production-
decision lens and adds a paper-track formal specification of the
router algorithm.
V2_DEEP_ANALYSIS_ZH.md changes:
- §0 TL;DR: lead with "online coding agent serving should pick
KVC 1P3D"; the only real cost is TTFT p99 long-tail (3x DP) from
the 8.3% mooncake reseed path, mitigable with real RDMA.
- §4 restructured into three buckets:
real costs (TTFT p99 tail, abort accounting now fixed),
counter-arguments to the critic (cache concentration and idle
prefill GPU are design intent, not deficits),
methodology to-do (naive-1P3D control, v2 N>=2 determinism).
- §6 replaces "5/1/3 rescoring" with production decision rationale:
KVC wins on 6 latency/TTFT metrics + lower failure rate; pays
TTFT p99 tail; lists workloads where DP would reverse the call.
- §8 decision points: D1 recommends Yes (accept v2 as milestone);
D8 added: paper motif "KVC trades P idle for TTFT stability."
KVC_ROUTER_ALGORITHM.md (new, paper-track, Chinese narrative + English
algorithm boxes / variable names / theorems for direct paper reuse):
- Problem formulation, system model, full notation
- Algorithm 1 Route: lexicographic-tuple scoring on
(overlap+alpha*sticky, sticky, -inflight, -assigned)
- Algorithm 2 Admit: D-worker autonomous admission deciding
Direct / Seed / Reseed / reject (with reason)
- Algorithm 3 Dispatch: end-to-end orchestration with reset-on-success
(the v2-specific fix that eliminates v1's self-amplifying thrashing)
- Theorem 1 (no permanent starvation) and Theorem 2 (fast-path
determinism), each with a proof sketch
- Comparison table vs vanilla pd-disagg / DP cache-aware
- Anti-patterns ("what KVC explicitly is NOT")
- Open questions for reviewers
- Suggested paper citation phrasing
- Appendix A: algorithm-step to source-file:line crosswalk
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
37e9caa431