{
  "contrast_decomposition": {
    "exact_state_matched_tp8_minus_tp4_ms": 10.902788634037428,
    "residual_vs_exact_iteration_ms": 1.7850640558340523,
    "residual_vs_frozen_real_tpot_ms": 3.9527886340374287,
    "simulator_internal_tp8_minus_tp4_ms": -20.06625468177714,
    "state_composition_shift_ms": 30.969043315814567
  },
  "exact_state_matched": {
    "configs": {
      "tp4_ep1_mns64": {
        "components_ms": {
          "attention": 7.861372580683772,
          "dense_mlp_compute": 0.20457670875208997,
          "ep_communication": 0.0,
          "moe_compute": 11.818199308522054,
          "moe_routing": 1.3660523028556315,
          "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
          "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
          "total": 34.25746674314369,
          "tp_dp_communication": 13.007265841334672
        },
        "coverage": 1.0,
        "supported_decode_tokens": 32895,
        "total_decode_tokens": 32895,
        "unsupported": {}
      },
      "tp8_ep8_mns64": {
        "components_ms": {
          "attention": 5.730952171784399,
          "dense_mlp_compute": 0.17382455581232167,
          "ep_communication": 6.535508227248577,
          "moe_compute": 9.840752983018692,
          "moe_routing": 1.5044582710663996,
          "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
          "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
          "total": 45.160255377181116,
          "tp_dp_communication": 6.535508227248577
        },
        "coverage": 1.0,
        "supported_decode_tokens": 32895,
        "total_decode_tokens": 32895,
        "unsupported": {}
      }
    },
    "method": "decode-token-weighted exact (context_tokens, generation_requests) composition from vLLM iteration details; no interpolation",
    "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
      "attention": -2.130420408899373,
      "dense_mlp_compute": -0.030752152939768296,
      "ep_communication": 6.535508227248577,
      "moe_compute": -1.9774463255033616,
      "moe_routing": 0.13840596821076812,
      "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
      "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
      "total": 10.902788634037428,
      "tp_dp_communication": -6.471757614086094
    }
  },
  "proxy_matched": {
    "configs": {
      "tp4_ep1_mns64": {
        "components_ms": {
          "attention": 6.303822560333333,
          "dense_mlp_compute": 0.17883562666666666,
          "ep_communication": 0.0,
          "moe_compute": 26.449277218333332,
          "moe_routing": 1.2571787503333332,
          "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
          "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
          "total": 46.414892970000004,
          "tp_dp_communication": 12.225778813333333
        },
        "coverage": 1.0,
        "supported_samples": 45,
        "total_samples": 45,
        "unsupported": {}
      },
      "tp8_ep8_mns64": {
        "components_ms": {
          "attention": 6.063134093052075,
          "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032000000073,
          "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
          "moe_compute": 10.391190702777717,
          "moe_routing": 1.5681029842793537,
          "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
          "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
          "total": 37.86318467071363,
          "tp_dp_communication": 6.824791048020123
        },
        "coverage": 1.0,
        "supported_samples": 21,
        "total_samples": 21,
        "unsupported": {}
      }
    },
    "method": "exact batch-size lookup; each simulator config is reweighted to its own frozen-real steady Running histogram; no interpolation",
    "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
      "attention": -0.2406884672812577,
      "dense_mlp_compute": 0.0017646933333340664,
      "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
      "moe_compute": -16.058086515555615,
      "moe_routing": 0.31092423394602053,
      "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
      "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
      "total": -8.551708299286375,
      "tp_dp_communication": -5.40098776531321
    }
  },
  "real": {
    "tp4_ep1_mns64": {
      "aggregate": {
        "generation_tokens_per_s": {
          "cv": 0.01219623132338527,
          "distinct_n": 32,
          "max": 217.3,
          "mean": 204.7488888888889,
          "min": 197.1,
          "n": 45
        },
        "kv_percent": {
          "cv": 0.09908502666308305,
          "distinct_n": 2,
          "max": 5.6,
          "mean": 5.233333333333333,
          "min": 4.5,
          "n": 45
        },
        "running": {
          "cv": 0.10101525445522107,
          "distinct_n": 2,
          "max": 5.0,
          "mean": 4.666666666666667,
          "min": 4.0,
          "n": 45
        },
        "running_histogram": {
          "4": 15,
          "5": 30
        },
        "samples": 45,
        "waiting": {
          "cv": 0.0,
          "distinct_n": 1,
          "max": 0.0,
          "mean": 0.0,
          "min": 0.0,
          "n": 45
        }
      },
      "proxy_only": true,
      "steady_rule": "prompt throughput >= 95% of 3276.8 tokens/s",
      "trials": [
        {
          "all_samples": 17,
          "generation_tokens_per_s": {
            "cv": 0.01635665678820842,
            "distinct_n": 13,
            "max": 217.3,
            "mean": 205.58666666666667,
            "min": 202.4,
            "n": 15
          },
          "kv_percent": {
            "cv": 0.0,
            "distinct_n": 1,
            "max": 5.6,
            "mean": 5.6,
            "min": 5.6,
            "n": 15
          },
          "path": "/home/admin/cpfs/wjh/aituner/qwen235-v020-fourcase-20260719-r1/real/fixed-pd/real/tp4_ep1_mns64/trial1/logs/server.log",
          "running": {
            "cv": 0.0,
            "distinct_n": 1,
            "max": 5.0,
            "mean": 5.0,
            "min": 5.0,
            "n": 15
          },
          "steady_samples": 15,
          "trial": "trial1",
          "waiting": {
            "cv": 0.0,
            "distinct_n": 1,
            "max": 0.0,
            "mean": 0.0,
            "min": 0.0,
            "n": 15
          }
        },
        {
          "all_samples": 17,
          "generation_tokens_per_s": {
            "cv": 0.01101205870299425,
            "distinct_n": 11,
            "max": 206.3,
            "mean": 204.18666666666667,
            "min": 197.1,
            "n": 15
          },
          "kv_percent": {
            "cv": 0.0,
            "distinct_n": 1,
            "max": 5.6,
            "mean": 5.6,
            "min": 5.6,
            "n": 15
          },
          "path": "/home/admin/cpfs/wjh/aituner/qwen235-v020-fourcase-20260719-r1/real/fixed-pd/real/tp4_ep1_mns64/trial2/logs/server.log",
          "running": {
            "cv": 0.0,
            "distinct_n": 1,
            "max": 5.0,
            "mean": 5.0,
            "min": 5.0,
            "n": 15
          },
          "steady_samples": 15,
          "trial": "trial2",
          "waiting": {
            "cv": 0.0,
            "distinct_n": 1,
            "max": 0.0,
            "mean": 0.0,
            "min": 0.0,
            "n": 15
          }
        },
        {
          "all_samples": 17,
          "generation_tokens_per_s": {
            "cv": 0.005467774668645034,
            "distinct_n": 14,
            "max": 206.0,
            "mean": 204.47333333333333,
            "min": 202.0,
            "n": 15
          },
          "kv_percent": {
            "cv": 0.0,
            "distinct_n": 1,
            "max": 4.5,
            "mean": 4.5,
            "min": 4.5,
            "n": 15
          },
          "path": "/home/admin/cpfs/wjh/aituner/qwen235-v020-fourcase-20260719-r1/real/fixed-pd/real/tp4_ep1_mns64/trial3/logs/server.log",
          "running": {
            "cv": 0.0,
            "distinct_n": 1,
            "max": 4.0,
            "mean": 4.0,
            "min": 4.0,
            "n": 15
          },
          "steady_samples": 15,
          "trial": "trial3",
          "waiting": {
            "cv": 0.0,
            "distinct_n": 1,
            "max": 0.0,
            "mean": 0.0,
            "min": 0.0,
            "n": 15
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    "tp8_ep8_mns64": {
      "aggregate": {
        "generation_tokens_per_s": {
          "cv": 0.01855015540813005,
          "distinct_n": 21,
          "max": 415.7,
          "mean": 406.5380952380952,
          "min": 390.8,
          "n": 21
        },
        "kv_percent": {
          "cv": 0.03973151445031385,
          "distinct_n": 3,
          "max": 5.6,
          "mean": 5.295238095238095,
          "min": 4.8,
          "n": 21
        },
        "running": {
          "cv": 0.04297805843263526,
          "distinct_n": 3,
          "max": 13.0,
          "mean": 12.238095238095237,
          "min": 11.0,
          "n": 21
        },
        "running_histogram": {
          "11": 1,
          "12": 14,
          "13": 6
        },
        "samples": 21,
        "waiting": {
          "cv": 0.0,
          "distinct_n": 1,
          "max": 0.0,
          "mean": 0.0,
          "min": 0.0,
          "n": 21
        }
      },
      "proxy_only": true,
      "steady_rule": "prompt throughput >= 95% of 6553.6 tokens/s",
      "trials": [
        {
          "all_samples": 9,
          "generation_tokens_per_s": {
            "cv": 0.018873398222858283,
            "distinct_n": 7,
            "max": 415.7,
            "mean": 406.87142857142857,
            "min": 392.3,
            "n": 7
          },
          "kv_percent": {
            "cv": 0.03400298559320833,
            "distinct_n": 2,
            "max": 5.6,
            "mean": 5.314285714285715,
            "min": 5.2,
            "n": 7
          },
          "path": "/home/admin/cpfs/wjh/aituner/qwen235-v020-fourcase-20260719-r1/real/fixed-pd/real/tp8_ep8_mns64/trial1/logs/server.log",
          "running": {
            "cv": 0.036770670467074176,
            "distinct_n": 2,
            "max": 13.0,
            "mean": 12.285714285714286,
            "min": 12.0,
            "n": 7
          },
          "steady_samples": 7,
          "trial": "trial1",
          "waiting": {
            "cv": 0.0,
            "distinct_n": 1,
            "max": 0.0,
            "mean": 0.0,
            "min": 0.0,
            "n": 7
          }
        },
        {
          "all_samples": 9,
          "generation_tokens_per_s": {
            "cv": 0.01869328742146201,
            "distinct_n": 7,
            "max": 412.9,
            "mean": 406.2857142857143,
            "min": 390.8,
            "n": 7
          },
          "kv_percent": {
            "cv": 0.04861017342390845,
            "distinct_n": 3,
            "max": 5.6,
            "mean": 5.257142857142857,
            "min": 4.8,
            "n": 7
          },
          "path": "/home/admin/cpfs/wjh/aituner/qwen235-v020-fourcase-20260719-r1/real/fixed-pd/real/tp8_ep8_mns64/trial2/logs/server.log",
          "running": {
            "cv": 0.052613364176465637,
            "distinct_n": 3,
            "max": 13.0,
            "mean": 12.142857142857142,
            "min": 11.0,
            "n": 7
          },
          "steady_samples": 7,
          "trial": "trial2",
          "waiting": {
            "cv": 0.0,
            "distinct_n": 1,
            "max": 0.0,
            "mean": 0.0,
            "min": 0.0,
            "n": 7
          }
        },
        {
          "all_samples": 9,
          "generation_tokens_per_s": {
            "cv": 0.018043345382112573,
            "distinct_n": 7,
            "max": 414.9,
            "mean": 406.45714285714286,
            "min": 393.0,
            "n": 7
          },
          "kv_percent": {
            "cv": 0.03400298559320833,
            "distinct_n": 2,
            "max": 5.6,
            "mean": 5.314285714285715,
            "min": 5.2,
            "n": 7
          },
          "path": "/home/admin/cpfs/wjh/aituner/qwen235-v020-fourcase-20260719-r1/real/fixed-pd/real/tp8_ep8_mns64/trial3/logs/server.log",
          "running": {
            "cv": 0.036770670467074176,
            "distinct_n": 2,
            "max": 13.0,
            "mean": 12.285714285714286,
            "min": 12.0,
            "n": 7
          },
          "steady_samples": 7,
          "trial": "trial3",
          "waiting": {
            "cv": 0.0,
            "distinct_n": 1,
            "max": 0.0,
            "mean": 0.0,
            "min": 0.0,
            "n": 7
          }
        }
      ]
    }
  },
  "real_iteration_state": {
    "tp4_ep1_mns64": {
      "decode_batch_size": {
        "cv": 0.13029119433004072,
        "distinct_n": 5,
        "max": 5.0,
        "mean": 3.8896771904930825,
        "min": 1.0,
        "n": 8457
      },
      "decode_bearing_rows": 8457,
      "decode_token_weighted_iteration_elapsed_ms": 18.47097461620307,
      "decode_token_weighted_joint_state_histogram": {
        "0:1": 149,
        "0:2": 280,
        "0:3": 621,
        "0:4": 31012,
        "0:5": 400,
        "4096:1": 1,
        "4096:2": 2,
        "4096:3": 222,
        "4096:4": 208
      },
      "measured_rows": 8460,
      "mixed_iteration_elapsed_ms": {
        "cv": 0.015940570375581706,
        "distinct_n": 114,
        "max": 350.16,
        "mean": 337.35875,
        "min": 331.36,
        "n": 128
      },
      "mixed_prefill_decode_rows": 128,
      "path": "/home/admin/cpfs/wjh/aituner/qwen235-fixed-pd-state-diagnosis-20260719-r1/iteration-real/tp4_ep1_mns64/logs/server.log",
      "pure_decode_batch_histogram": {
        "1": 149,
        "2": 140,
        "3": 207,
        "4": 7753,
        "5": 80
      },
      "pure_decode_iteration_elapsed_ms": {
        "cv": 0.0683725733639485,
        "distinct_n": 353,
        "max": 63.66,
        "mean": 14.141689278424781,
        "min": 0.11,
        "n": 8329
      },
      "pure_decode_rows": 8329
    },
    "tp8_ep8_mns64": {
      "decode_batch_size": {
        "cv": 0.24310653962915885,
        "distinct_n": 13,
        "max": 13.0,
        "mean": 10.921314741035857,
        "min": 1.0,
        "n": 3012
      },
      "decode_bearing_rows": 3012,
      "decode_token_weighted_iteration_elapsed_ms": 27.588699194406445,
      "decode_token_weighted_joint_state_histogram": {
        "0:1": 49,
        "0:10": 700,
        "0:11": 2431,
        "0:12": 24312,
        "0:13": 2067,
        "0:2": 96,
        "0:3": 138,
        "0:4": 196,
        "0:5": 215,
        "0:6": 270,
        "0:7": 315,
        "0:8": 352,
        "0:9": 351,
        "4096:1": 1,
        "4096:10": 40,
        "4096:11": 682,
        "4096:12": 636,
        "4096:2": 2,
        "4096:3": 3,
        "4096:4": 4,
        "4096:5": 5,
        "4096:6": 6,
        "4096:7": 7,
        "4096:8": 8,
        "4096:9": 9
      },
      "measured_rows": 3015,
      "mixed_iteration_elapsed_ms": {
        "cv": 0.04096511316969508,
        "distinct_n": 126,
        "max": 345.82,
        "mean": 319.430703125,
        "min": 294.13,
        "n": 128
      },
      "mixed_prefill_decode_rows": 128,
      "path": "/home/admin/cpfs/wjh/aituner/qwen235-fixed-pd-state-diagnosis-20260719-r1/iteration-real/tp8_ep8_mns64/logs/server.log",
      "pure_decode_batch_histogram": {
        "1": 49,
        "10": 70,
        "11": 221,
        "12": 2026,
        "13": 159,
        "2": 48,
        "3": 46,
        "4": 49,
        "5": 43,
        "6": 45,
        "7": 45,
        "8": 44,
        "9": 39
      },
      "pure_decode_iteration_elapsed_ms": {
        "cv": 0.08468104731049882,
        "distinct_n": 347,
        "max": 20.05,
        "mean": 14.330596393897366,
        "min": 9.46,
        "n": 2884
      },
      "pure_decode_rows": 2884
    }
  },
  "reference": {
    "exact_iteration_tp8_minus_tp4_ms": 9.117724578203376,
    "observed_real_tp8_minus_tp4_ms": 6.949999999999999,
    "real_tpot_ms": {
      "tp4_ep1_mns64": 21.0442,
      "tp8_ep8_mns64": 27.9942
    }
  },
  "same_batch_contrasts": {
    "1": {
      "tp4_n": 54,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.8935417788173714,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 5.551115123125783e-17,
        "ep_communication": 7.6409967723488785,
        "moe_compute": -1.3674890128222263,
        "moe_routing": 0.24700169495130986,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -8.382111054979667,
        "tp_dp_communication": -6.785968403651121
      },
      "tp8_n": 34
    },
    "10": {
      "tp4_n": 38,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.9062451258095203,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 7.216449660063518e-16,
        "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
        "moe_compute": -30.78018275622229,
        "moe_routing": 0.27075982727935366,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -23.288943843339915,
        "tp_dp_communication": -4.708641311979878
      },
      "tp8_n": 22
    },
    "11": {
      "tp4_n": 42,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.90756947260952,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 7.216449660063518e-16,
        "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
        "moe_compute": -30.78018275622229,
        "moe_routing": 0.2707598272793539,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -23.29026819009679,
        "tp_dp_communication": -4.708641311979878
      },
      "tp8_n": 22
    },
    "12": {
      "tp4_n": 46,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.90756947260952,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 7.216449660063518e-16,
        "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
        "moe_compute": -30.780182756222285,
        "moe_routing": 0.27075982727935366,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -23.290268190109693,
        "tp_dp_communication": -4.708641311979878
      },
      "tp8_n": 21
    },
    "13": {
      "tp4_n": 46,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.9271714387939403,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 7.771561172376096e-16,
        "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
        "moe_compute": -30.78018275622228,
        "moe_routing": 0.27075982727935366,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -23.309870155730238,
        "tp_dp_communication": -4.708641311979878
      },
      "tp8_n": 22
    },
    "14": {
      "tp4_n": 47,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.9273699663939379,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 6.938893903907228e-16,
        "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
        "moe_compute": -30.78018275622229,
        "moe_routing": 0.27075982727935366,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -23.310068683979324,
        "tp_dp_communication": -4.708641311979878
      },
      "tp8_n": 21
    },
    "15": {
      "tp4_n": 663,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.9280176641939368,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 6.938893903907228e-16,
        "ep_communication": 6.824791048020124,
        "moe_compute": -30.78018275622229,
        "moe_routing": 0.2707598272793539,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -23.310716381302065,
        "tp_dp_communication": -4.708641311979875
      },
      "tp8_n": 21
    },
    "16": {
      "tp4_n": 1053,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.9280176641939377,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 7.216449660063518e-16,
        "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
        "moe_compute": -30.78018275622229,
        "moe_routing": 0.27075982727935366,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -23.310716381309007,
        "tp_dp_communication": -4.708641311979878
      },
      "tp8_n": 22
    },
    "2": {
      "tp4_n": 52,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.893056937985337,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 5.551115123125783e-17,
        "ep_communication": 7.170214735418557,
        "moe_compute": -2.487079396822226,
        "moe_routing": 0.23761673495131297,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -7.529038359797266,
        "tp_dp_communication": -6.276494110581443
      },
      "tp8_n": 32
    },
    "3": {
      "tp4_n": 47,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.8994740207853011,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 8.326672684688674e-17,
        "ep_communication": 6.661276281625032,
        "moe_compute": -4.971655204025423,
        "moe_routing": 0.23007132819364218,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -9.72273303992905,
        "tp_dp_communication": -6.0593006383749675
      },
      "tp8_n": 31
    },
    "4": {
      "tp4_n": 48,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.9032519198967934,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 5.551115123125783e-17,
        "ep_communication": 6.661276281625032,
        "moe_compute": -4.971655204025423,
        "moe_routing": 0.23007132819364196,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -9.726510939439532,
        "tp_dp_communication": -6.0593006383749675
      },
      "tp8_n": 30
    },
    "5": {
      "tp4_n": 34,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.8975988783634543,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 7.494005416219807e-16,
        "ep_communication": 6.619871115982532,
        "moe_compute": -25.90819860140641,
        "moe_routing": 0.2783929890825345,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -28.211543726727538,
        "tp_dp_communication": -5.358508644017467
      },
      "tp8_n": 27
    },
    "6": {
      "tp4_n": 33,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.8977163413634548,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 7.216449660063518e-16,
        "ep_communication": 6.619871115982532,
        "moe_compute": -25.90819860140641,
        "moe_routing": 0.2783929890825343,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -28.211661189448645,
        "tp_dp_communication": -5.358508644017467
      },
      "tp8_n": 26
    },
    "7": {
      "tp4_n": 34,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.9209473308539557,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 7.216449660063518e-16,
        "ep_communication": 6.619871115982532,
        "moe_compute": -25.908198601406404,
        "moe_routing": 0.2783929890825345,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -28.23489217903426,
        "tp_dp_communication": -5.358508644017467
      },
      "tp8_n": 26
    },
    "8": {
      "tp4_n": 33,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.9209473308539557,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 7.216449660063518e-16,
        "ep_communication": 6.619871115982532,
        "moe_compute": -25.90819860140641,
        "moe_routing": 0.27839298908253474,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -28.23489217902994,
        "tp_dp_communication": -5.358508644017467
      },
      "tp8_n": 27
    },
    "9": {
      "tp4_n": 32,
      "tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
        "attention": -0.9096465718095201,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 7.216449660063518e-16,
        "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
        "moe_compute": -30.78018275622229,
        "moe_routing": 0.27075982727935366,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": -23.292345289360462,
        "tp_dp_communication": -4.708641311979878
      },
      "tp8_n": 21
    }
  },
  "schema": "qwen235-fixed-pd-state-diagnosis-v1",
  "scope": {
    "graph_observability": "Frontier state outputs have no direct graph bucket/padding/launch-overhead field; graph effects remain folded into predictors",
    "op_trace_accounting": "For TP8 shared-domain sync, total is ledger stage_end-start (critical path); op categories are serialized work estimates and are not additive because overlap and lane-summed wait diagnostics are represented separately",
    "real_proxy_limitation": "vLLM 10-second Running is active requests, not per-iteration decode batch; context lengths and graph buckets are unavailable in frozen logs",
    "workload": "Fixed-PD 4096->256, 0.2 req/s/GPU, MNS64"
  },
  "simulator": {
    "tp4_ep1_mns64": {
      "batch_support": {
        "1": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 5.918822475999999,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.177568256,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 4.277032336,
            "moe_routing": 1.234618249,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 26.035006493,
            "tp_dp_communication": 14.426965176
          },
          "n": 54
        },
        "10": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.795322718,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 41.171373459,
            "moe_routing": 1.297343157,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 60.978072013,
            "tp_dp_communication": 11.53343236
          },
          "n": 38
        },
        "11": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.8427973799999995,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 41.171373459,
            "moe_routing": 1.297343157,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 61.025546675,
            "tp_dp_communication": 11.53343236
          },
          "n": 42
        },
        "12": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.84279738,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 41.171373459,
            "moe_routing": 1.297343157,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 61.02554667500001,
            "tp_dp_communication": 11.53343236
          },
          "n": 46
        },
        "13": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 7.310070996000001,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060031999999998,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 41.171373458999994,
            "moe_routing": 1.297343157,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 61.492820290999994,
            "tp_dp_communication": 11.53343236
          },
          "n": 46
        },
        "14": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 7.316185658,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032000000004,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 41.171373459,
            "moe_routing": 1.297343157,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 61.49893495300001,
            "tp_dp_communication": 11.53343236
          },
          "n": 47
        },
        "15": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 7.332662654999999,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032000000004,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 41.171373459,
            "moe_routing": 1.297343157,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 61.51541195,
            "tp_dp_communication": 11.533432359999999
          },
          "n": 663
        },
        "16": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 7.332662655,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 41.171373459,
            "moe_routing": 1.297343157,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 61.51541195,
            "tp_dp_communication": 11.53343236
          },
          "n": 1053
        },
        "2": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.048001424230768,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.177568256,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 5.39662272,
            "moe_routing": 1.237987209,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 26.30688845623077,
            "tp_dp_communication": 13.446708846
          },
          "n": 52
        },
        "3": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.09964707180851,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.177568256,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 9.978847425,
            "moe_routing": 1.2434858329999998,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 30.22012550680851,
            "tp_dp_communication": 12.72057692
          },
          "n": 47
        },
        "4": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.285367077,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.177568256,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 9.978847425,
            "moe_routing": 1.243485833,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 30.405845512,
            "tp_dp_communication": 12.72057692
          },
          "n": 48
        },
        "5": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.313050302,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.17946931199999996,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 34.684492115,
            "moe_routing": 1.264025209,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 54.419416699,
            "tp_dp_communication": 11.97837976
          },
          "n": 34
        },
        "6": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.356479957,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.179469312,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 34.684492115,
            "moe_routing": 1.264025209,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 54.462846354,
            "tp_dp_communication": 11.97837976
          },
          "n": 33
        },
        "7": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.734075413,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.179469312,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 34.68449211499999,
            "moe_routing": 1.264025209,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 54.84044181,
            "tp_dp_communication": 11.97837976
          },
          "n": 34
        },
        "8": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.734075413,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.179469312,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 34.684492115,
            "moe_routing": 1.264025209,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 54.84044181,
            "tp_dp_communication": 11.97837976
          },
          "n": 33
        },
        "9": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.782511044,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032,
            "ep_communication": 0.0,
            "moe_compute": 41.171373459,
            "moe_routing": 1.297343157,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 60.965260339,
            "tp_dp_communication": 11.53343236
          },
          "n": 32
        }
      },
      "component_source": "stage_batch_ledger",
      "decode_batch_size": {
        "cv": 0.3076467178753811,
        "distinct_n": 16,
        "max": 16.0,
        "mean": 13.537037037037036,
        "min": 1.0,
        "n": 2430
      },
      "decode_bearing_rows": 2430,
      "decode_token_weighted_all_step_components_ms": {
        "attention": 13.842547047292292,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 0.2927251518073871,
        "ep_communication": 0.0,
        "moe_compute": 45.47878637854458,
        "moe_routing": 1.8023597240381213,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": 74.2229273813438,
        "tp_dp_communication": 12.806509080469617
      },
      "decode_token_weighted_mixed_step_share": 0.05481076151390789,
      "mixed_prefill_decode_rows": 128,
      "pure_decode_rows": 2302,
      "pure_decode_token_weighted_components_ms": {
        "attention": 7.263972797140871,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18052079084832112,
        "ep_communication": 0.0,
        "moe_compute": 40.472043520877655,
        "moe_routing": 1.2955265717923583,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": 60.78208599545992,
        "tp_dp_communication": 11.57002231571491
      },
      "scorer_equivalence": {
        "base_metrics": {
          "e2e_mean_ms": 19261.684938205322,
          "e2e_p50_ms": 19681.421068277567,
          "e2e_p90_ms": 19712.678973231064,
          "e2e_p95_ms": 19717.18006692948,
          "slos": {
            "tpot_100ms": {
              "feasible": true,
              "pass_rate": 1.0,
              "passed": 129
            },
            "tpot_150ms": {
              "feasible": true,
              "pass_rate": 1.0,
              "passed": 129
            },
            "tpot_180ms": {
              "feasible": true,
              "pass_rate": 1.0,
              "passed": 129
            },
            "tpot_50ms": {
              "feasible": false,
              "pass_rate": 0.0,
              "passed": 0
            }
          },
          "tpot_mean_ms": 74.22292738142716,
          "tpot_p50_ms": 75.8976524911963,
          "tpot_p90_ms": 75.8976524912086,
          "tpot_p95_ms": 75.89765249120967,
          "ttft_mean_ms": 334.8384559413977,
          "ttft_p50_ms": 334.75193988430976,
          "ttft_p90_ms": 359.7779859328796,
          "ttft_p95_ms": 363.2786816744229
        },
        "request_metrics_byte_identical": true,
        "request_metrics_sha256": "01ed41e9babf2eb71286e93d8f4986dda9820f92212c975ed9411a95a5f8758f"
      },
      "stage_rows": 2431,
      "trace_validation": null
    },
    "tp8_ep8_mns64": {
      "batch_support": {
        "1": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 5.025280697182628,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.17756825600000006,
            "ep_communication": 7.6409967723488785,
            "moe_compute": 2.909543323177774,
            "moe_routing": 1.4816199439513098,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 17.652895438020334,
            "tp_dp_communication": 7.6409967723488785
          },
          "n": 34
        },
        "10": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 5.88907759219048,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032000000073,
            "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
            "moe_compute": 10.391190702777715,
            "moe_routing": 1.5681029842793537,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 37.68912816966009,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.824791048020123
          },
          "n": 22
        },
        "11": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 5.9352279073904795,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032000000073,
            "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
            "moe_compute": 10.391190702777715,
            "moe_routing": 1.568102984279354,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 37.73527848490321,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.824791048020123
          },
          "n": 22
        },
        "12": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 5.93522790739048,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032000000073,
            "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
            "moe_compute": 10.391190702777717,
            "moe_routing": 1.5681029842793537,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 37.735278484890316,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.824791048020123
          },
          "n": 21
        },
        "13": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.382899557206061,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032000000076,
            "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
            "moe_compute": 10.391190702777715,
            "moe_routing": 1.5681029842793537,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 38.182950135269756,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.824791048020123
          },
          "n": 22
        },
        "14": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.388815691606062,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032000000073,
            "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
            "moe_compute": 10.391190702777715,
            "moe_routing": 1.5681029842793537,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 38.188866269020686,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.824791048020123
          },
          "n": 21
        },
        "15": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.404644990806062,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032000000073,
            "ep_communication": 6.824791048020124,
            "moe_compute": 10.391190702777713,
            "moe_routing": 1.568102984279354,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 38.204695568697936,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.824791048020124
          },
          "n": 21
        },
        "16": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.404644990806062,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032000000073,
            "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
            "moe_compute": 10.391190702777715,
            "moe_routing": 1.5681029842793537,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 38.204695568690994,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.824791048020123
          },
          "n": 22
        },
        "17": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.652331067872723,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18267583999999898,
            "ep_communication": 6.763788700699805,
            "moe_compute": 14.63356500064447,
            "moe_routing": 1.647955106498404,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 39.2554552675483,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.763788700699805
          },
          "n": 31
        },
        "18": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.652331067872723,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18267583999999898,
            "ep_communication": 6.763788700699805,
            "moe_compute": 14.633565000644474,
            "moe_routing": 1.647955106498404,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 39.25545526754183,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.763788700699805
          },
          "n": 30
        },
        "19": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.652331067872723,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18267583999999898,
            "ep_communication": 6.763788700699805,
            "moe_compute": 14.633565000644472,
            "moe_routing": 1.647955106498404,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 39.25545526755436,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.763788700699805
          },
          "n": 32
        },
        "2": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 5.154944486245431,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.17756825600000006,
            "ep_communication": 7.170214735418557,
            "moe_compute": 2.909543323177774,
            "moe_routing": 1.475603943951313,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 18.777850096433504,
            "tp_dp_communication": 7.170214735418557
          },
          "n": 32
        },
        "20": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.652331067872723,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18267583999999898,
            "ep_communication": 6.763788700699804,
            "moe_compute": 14.633565000644472,
            "moe_routing": 1.6479551064984042,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 39.25545526756006,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.763788700699804
          },
          "n": 33
        },
        "21": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.9837604522698395,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18267583999999895,
            "ep_communication": 6.763788700699806,
            "moe_compute": 14.633565000644474,
            "moe_routing": 1.6479551064984037,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 39.58688465210873,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.763788700699806
          },
          "n": 37
        },
        "22": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.9837604522698395,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18267583999999898,
            "ep_communication": 6.763788700699805,
            "moe_compute": 14.633565000644472,
            "moe_routing": 1.6479551064984042,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 39.586884652057584,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.763788700699805
          },
          "n": 51
        },
        "23": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.9837604522698395,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.182675839999999,
            "ep_communication": 6.763788700699805,
            "moe_compute": 14.63356500064447,
            "moe_routing": 1.647955106498404,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 39.58688465207786,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.763788700699805
          },
          "n": 906
        },
        "24": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 6.9837604522698395,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18267583999999895,
            "ep_communication": 6.763788700699805,
            "moe_compute": 14.633565000644472,
            "moe_routing": 1.6479551064984037,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 39.58688465207813,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.763788700699805
          },
          "n": 84
        },
        "3": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 5.200173051023209,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.1775682560000001,
            "ep_communication": 6.661276281625032,
            "moe_compute": 5.007192220974576,
            "moe_routing": 1.473557161193642,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 20.49739246687946,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.661276281625032
          },
          "n": 31
        },
        "4": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 5.382115157103207,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.17756825600000006,
            "ep_communication": 6.661276281625032,
            "moe_compute": 5.007192220974576,
            "moe_routing": 1.473557161193642,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 20.679334572560467,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.661276281625032
          },
          "n": 30
        },
        "5": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 5.415451423636545,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.1794693120000007,
            "ep_communication": 6.619871115982532,
            "moe_compute": 8.776293513593586,
            "moe_routing": 1.5424181980825344,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 26.207872972272465,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.619871115982532
          },
          "n": 27
        },
        "6": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 5.4587636156365456,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.1794693120000007,
            "ep_communication": 6.619871115982532,
            "moe_compute": 8.776293513593586,
            "moe_routing": 1.5424181980825342,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 26.251185164551355,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.619871115982532
          },
          "n": 26
        },
        "7": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 5.8131280821460445,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.1794693120000007,
            "ep_communication": 6.619871115982532,
            "moe_compute": 8.776293513593586,
            "moe_routing": 1.5424181980825344,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 26.60554963096574,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.619871115982532
          },
          "n": 26
        },
        "8": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 5.8131280821460445,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.1794693120000007,
            "ep_communication": 6.619871115982532,
            "moe_compute": 8.776293513593586,
            "moe_routing": 1.5424181980825347,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 26.60554963097006,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.619871115982532
          },
          "n": 27
        },
        "9": {
          "components_ms": {
            "attention": 5.8728644721904795,
            "dense_mlp_compute": 0.18060032000000073,
            "ep_communication": 6.824791048020123,
            "moe_compute": 10.391190702777715,
            "moe_routing": 1.5681029842793537,
            "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
            "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
            "total": 37.672915049639535,
            "tp_dp_communication": 6.824791048020123
          },
          "n": 21
        }
      },
      "component_source": "op_trace_execution_time_override",
      "decode_batch_size": {
        "cv": 0.3602756967919564,
        "distinct_n": 24,
        "max": 24.0,
        "mean": 18.93782383419689,
        "min": 1.0,
        "n": 1737
      },
      "decode_bearing_rows": 1737,
      "decode_token_weighted_all_step_components_ms": {
        "attention": 6.38060442207261,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 0.16958377884622666,
        "ep_communication": 6.235402017662346,
        "moe_compute": 13.024343946852467,
        "moe_routing": 1.5161854734738416,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": 54.156672699566656,
        "tp_dp_communication": 6.235402017662346
      },
      "decode_token_weighted_mixed_step_share": 0.08077215382276942,
      "mixed_prefill_decode_rows": 128,
      "pure_decode_rows": 1609,
      "pure_decode_token_weighted_components_ms": {
        "attention": 6.853695012970485,
        "dense_mlp_compute": 0.1824026696707446,
        "ep_communication": 6.765971286395407,
        "moe_compute": 14.092651702097841,
        "moe_routing": 1.638092363428458,
        "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
        "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
        "total": 38.94606316261678,
        "tp_dp_communication": 6.765971286395407
      },
      "scorer_equivalence": {
        "base_metrics": {
          "e2e_mean_ms": 14056.464119438264,
          "e2e_p50_ms": 14650.653983203298,
          "e2e_p90_ms": 14674.997135818061,
          "e2e_p95_ms": 14677.859760866291,
          "slos": {
            "tpot_100ms": {
              "feasible": true,
              "pass_rate": 1.0,
              "passed": 129
            },
            "tpot_150ms": {
              "feasible": true,
              "pass_rate": 1.0,
              "passed": 129
            },
            "tpot_180ms": {
              "feasible": true,
              "pass_rate": 1.0,
              "passed": 129
            },
            "tpot_50ms": {
              "feasible": false,
              "pass_rate": 0.14728682170542637,
              "passed": 19
            }
          },
          "tpot_mean_ms": 54.15667269956665,
          "tpot_p50_ms": 56.52350191837838,
          "tpot_p90_ms": 56.52350850045728,
          "tpot_p95_ms": 56.523546100039816,
          "ttft_mean_ms": 246.51258104876885,
          "ttft_p50_ms": 246.7781280760306,
          "ttft_p90_ms": 263.0087113349084,
          "ttft_p95_ms": 264.77576248352364
        },
        "request_metrics_byte_identical": true,
        "request_metrics_sha256": "51a848c4c12eacabbc72a0f6a8b5c1863e8b624b316b7ab55341e3fe5a3a753b"
      },
      "stage_rows": 1738,
      "trace_validation": {
        "diagnostic_wait_ms": {
          "cv": 0.3169483933455645,
          "distinct_n": 26,
          "max": 67.2823542576566,
          "mean": 38.03960569005978,
          "min": 7.116029381293295,
          "n": 1609
        },
        "event_names": {
          "attn_decode": 1737,
          "attn_kv_cache_save": 1738,
          "attn_post_proj": 1738,
          "attn_pre_proj": 1738,
          "attn_prefill": 129,
          "attn_rope": 1738,
          "attn_tensor_parallel_allreduce": 1738,
          "expert_parallel_allreduce": 1738,
          "expert_parallel_allreduce_wait": 1609,
          "input_layernorm": 1738,
          "moe_gating_linear": 1738,
          "moe_gating_routing_topk": 1738,
          "moe_grouped_gemm": 1738,
          "moe_shuffling": 1738,
          "post_attention_layernorm": 1738
        },
        "ledger_batches": 1738,
        "serialized_component_sum_over_stage_span": {
          "cv": 0.30467075878025907,
          "distinct_n": 69,
          "max": 1.4091742542979306,
          "mean": 0.8931198465670052,
          "min": 0.010604399884068217,
          "n": 1738
        },
        "trace_batches": 1738,
        "trace_path": "/home/admin/cpfs/wjh/aituner/qwen235-fixed-pd-state-diagnosis-20260719-r1/frontier-optrace/tp8_ep8_mns64/frontier_metrics/qwen3_235b_a22b/online_serving/qwen235_fixed_pd_state_tp8_ep8_mns64/op_traces.jsonl"
      }
    }
  },
  "simulator_internal_all_step_tp8_minus_tp4_ms": {
    "attention": -7.461942625219683,
    "dense_mlp_compute": -0.12314137296116046,
    "ep_communication": 6.235402017662346,
    "moe_compute": -32.45444243169211,
    "moe_routing": -0.2861742505642797,
    "pipeline_communication": 0.0,
    "runtime_overhead": 0.0,
    "total": -20.06625468177714,
    "tp_dp_communication": -6.571107062807271
  },
  "status": "PASS",
  "verdict": "Exact real state composition flips Frontier to the correct TP4 winner; the ranking error is caused by closed-loop state/composition mismatch, not a conditional stage reversal."
}