- run 12: dim1664/22L true-GQA 1.05B base, seq1024, 6.765B FineWeb tokens,
81h on 8x5090. Fixed eval v1 @seq1024 = 2.7410 vs v11 2.7467 — a real but
marginal gain; v11->v12 is a capacity-only step on fixed data, so the ~0.2%
return confirms the 1B base is now data-limited.
- run 13: three SFT stages from the v12 base (synthetic / anchor /
real-mix-repair). The pipeline works and produces a chat-shaped model that
follows the format and stops, but none of the variants is a stable
high-quality chat model — bottleneck is SFT data quality + selection signal
(val loss decouples from generation quality), not infra.
- scripts/run_v12_phase.sh wrapper + chat_alpha_fixed_prompts.txt eval set.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Enable assistant-only supervised fine-tuning and a fixed chat-prompt eval path
used by the v12 SFT runs:
- cross_entropy ignores negative targets (-100 ignore-index), normalizing by
valid rows instead of all rows; CUDA fwd/bwd skip t<0 (ops.rs, nn.cu).
- Corpus gains optional labels + load_sft_tsv_cached: two-column TSV is
formatted as 'User: .. \nAssistant:' + answer + <|endoftext|>, prompt tokens
masked to -100 while answer+EOS are supervised; i32 label cache alongside the
u16 token cache; sample() retries windows that are fully masked; eval uses
target_window so masking applies to val loss too (data.rs, train_loop.rs).
- train + train_ddp: --sft-tsv selects the TSV loader, --init-ckpt continues
training from a base checkpoint.
- greedy_sample: --prompts-file/--prompt/--temperature for fixed chat-prompt
generation eval.
Test fixtures updated for the new Corpus.labels field; dropout.rs carries
incidental rustfmt. Not rebuilt locally (no CUDA toolchain on this checkout);
correctness rests on the documented v12 base+SFT runs on the GPU box.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Add per-run design+result docs for the two Chinchilla-axis runs that were
done but never committed:
- v9 (dim1280 true-GQA, core 357M, 6.01B FineWeb tokens): double-axis scale,
best moving-tail val 2.8854 (~3.2% below v8) — direction validated, gain
still incremental, greedy repetition remains.
- v10 (same arch, data-only top-up to 6.765B): moving-tail 2.8816; fixed
eval v1 v6→v10 = 3.2328/3.1850/3.1515/2.9278/2.8814.
Extend the comparison tables in docs/runs/README.md and docs/evolution.md to
v10, and reframe README to v0–v10 with Phase 3 = the v9 double-axis run. No
code changes.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- known-issues.md: new "DDP-dropout wiring" Fixed entry (gap + fix +
regression test), with the meta-lesson that op/single-GPU unit tests can
miss launcher-level integration gaps — only the V9-PILOT end-to-end run on
the real launcher path exposed it.
- 17-dropout.md: annotate the DDP-combination note with the T18 wiring gap
and its T21 fix.
- evolution.md: T21 row (Infra) recording the fix + meta-lesson.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds ddp_dropout_is_live_and_p0_bit_identical, run via the real launcher
path (DdpContext::init + train_rank). It would have caught the original bug:
- GATE A (world=1, ONE step — the deterministic scope): the p=0 FORWARD is
byte-identical to no-dropout (ops::dropout(p=0) is a graph no-op) so the
step loss is BIT-IDENTICAL (== 0.0). At world=1 the NCCL all-reduce
short-circuits and one step has no optimizer-state compounding; the only
residual non-determinism is the engine's atomicAdd backward-reduction
order (the documented fresh-train md5 caveat — dropout-independent), so the
post-step params are checked against that tight ULP floor (< 1e-7).
- GATE A2 (world=2): p=0 matches a separate no-dropout baseline within NCCL's
run-to-run ULP noise (< 1e-6, KI-5 — the all-reduce is not bit-reproducible
on this PCIe box). Enabling dropout=0 doesn't perturb the DDP path beyond it.
- GATE B (world=2): a p=0.2 run's loss trace DIFFERS by > 1e-3 from p=0 —
orders of magnitude above every noise floor here (~3e-2 observed). On the
pre-T21 code the model stays in eval mode, so p=0.2 would be an identity and
the trace would match p=0 at the noise floor — this gate fails. (Verified by
simulating the bug: with model.train() removed, GATE B drops to 2.4e-7.)
- GATE C: a dedicated no-eval run ends with model.is_training() == true,
direct proof that train_rank called model.train().
- p>0 run is finite (no NaN/Inf).
eval_every < steps so a periodic eval fires mid-run (flipping to eval mode),
exercising the per-step model.train() restore discipline the pilot called out.
Run with --test-threads=1 like the other DDP tests (shared-GPU deadlock).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
V9-PILOT caught a launcher-level integration gap: T18 wired dropout into
the single-GPU bin/train, but the DDP path never did. train_ddp had no
--dropout flag and never set cfg.dropout, and ddp.rs::train_rank never
called model.train() — so under DDP every forward ran in the default eval
mode and dropout was a silent identity, regardless of config.
Fix, mirroring the single-GPU train/eval discipline:
- train_ddp.rs: add a --dropout <p> flag (default 0 = off, matching the
prior behavior) and set cfg.dropout from it; log it when on.
- ddp.rs::train_rank: call model.train() at the start of each step (before
the micro-batch loop). eval_loss() flips the model to eval mode and does
not restore it, so re-asserting train() each step keeps dropout live
across eval boundaries.
--dropout 0 (default) is bit-identical to the prior DDP path: cfg.dropout
stays 0 and ops::dropout(p=0) is a clone no-op regardless of training mode.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Re-conclude xtrain as TWO phases now that Phase-2 (T14–T18) is merged on main:
README.md
- Status header: "complete (T1–T13) + scaling v0–v8" → "complete — two phases"
(Phase 1 = from-scratch stack T1–T13 + v0–v8 scaling study; Phase 2 = the five
deferred systems-stack features T14–T18).
- Crate table: note the Phase-2 additions (fused flash-attn + repeat_kv + dropout
in autodiff; GQA + dropout in model; grad-accum in train; process-per-GPU
launcher in distributed).
- Build-journey section retitled Phase 1 + Phase 2; replaced the run-on T14–T18
prose with a structured "## Phase 2" summary (5 features + honest results:
flash = mem-not-walltime win, GQA group-sum backward, grad-accum −74% mem,
dropout × recompute bit-exact, T17 throughput-neutral falsification).
- Engineering lessons: T17 added as the THIRD profile-first falsification;
reinforced honest-correctness with the Phase-2 hard gates + md5 b04fc9f9.
- Doc index: doc range …14-* → …17-*; KI status line (process-per-GPU CLOSED,
KI-4 accepted tradeoff).
docs/evolution.md
- New "三·五、Phase 2 systems-depth synthesis": ties the 5 features into the
per-axis (算法/架构/Infra/数据) narrative + the two integration notes.
docs/known-issues.md
- KI-4 reframed as a deliberately-accepted modeling tradeoff (保 xserv closed
loop; T19 DROPPED), not "open".
- New integration notes: (a) DDP tests need --test-threads=1 (parallel deadlock);
(b) fresh-train md5 is non-deterministic (atomicAdd reduction order) → the valid
determinism gate is export re-determinism, not fresh-train reproduction.
- (process-per-GPU item was already CLOSED=measured no-op in T17.)
Docs-only; no code touched.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Records the key empirical finding: process-per-GPU is statistically identical
to thread-per-GPU at this scale (thread 5.27x vs proc 5.31x @8, <1% noise; all
8 GPUs 95-99% util). The residual ~5.3x@8 non-linearity is the NCCL/PCIe
communication wall, NOT single-CUDA-context launch/cuBLAS serialization as the
old KI-5/T11 note speculated — measurement falsifies that hypothesis (same
methodology as T11 falsifying "bucket the all-reduce"). Correctness all green:
proc==thread loss 1.5e-7, cross-rank 1.2e-7, full regression + xserv md5
b04fc9f9 identical. Closes the process-per-GPU backlog item (measured no-op);
default training path unchanged. evolution.md Infra row + README T17 row +
known-issues entry.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Dual-mode binary self-detecting via XTRAIN_RANK: launcher spawns one worker
per visible GPU forwarding full argv; worker rebuilds config from argv and runs
run_worker. CLI flags identical to train_ddp (thread-per-GPU, kept), so it
doubles as the before->after throughput driver. thread-per-GPU path untouched.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
torchrun-style process-per-GPU: launch_processes spawns one worker process per
GPU (re-exec current_exe with XTRAIN_{RANK,WORLD,LOCAL_RANK,NCCL_ID} env),
mints the ncclUniqueId once in the launcher and hex-injects it via env (no
shared FS/TCP, race-free). worker_env/run_worker read the env, bind the device
(own CUDA context), DdpContext::init + build_model + train_rank reused from T8
UNCHANGED. hex_encode/decode_unique_id are host-testable pure fns.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
torchrun-style: launcher spawns N worker processes, each with its own CUDA
context; cross-process ncclUniqueId distributed via launcher-minted hex env
injection (race-free, no shared FS / TCP); train_rank + grad all-reduce reused
unchanged. Keeps thread-per-GPU path as regression baseline. ZeRO-1 dropped
(user scope decision).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- repeat_kv CUDA kernel: fwd head-block gather, bwd DETERMINISTIC group-sum (each
kv head sums its group of query-head grads; no atomics) + Tensor/ops node.
- Config gains num_kv_heads (default = n_heads → MHA); wk/wv project to kv_dim;
attention() repeat_kv-broadcasts K/V to nh heads before the UNCHANGED composed
& flash SDPA → GQA on both paths. group=1 is identity → MHA bit-identical.
- --kv-heads flag on train/train_ddp/export_safetensors/greedy_sample; export
writes real num_key_value_heads (xserv repeat_kv grouping aligned).
- Tests: repeat_kv grad-check (group>1 grad-sum + group=1 identity); model gqa.rs
(GQA flash==composed fp32/bf16, group=1 bit-identical to MHA, kv-proj shape);
parity_dump+parity.py GQA path (repeat_interleave) via XTRAIN_PARITY_KV_HEADS.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Add flash_plus_dropout_grad_check_fp32 to xtrain-model dropout tests: the two
orthogonal Phase-2 features (T14 flash-attn, T18 dropout) in the same model must
still grad-check. Both models run train-mode p=0.2 (identical masks, seed is
flash-independent) so the only delta is the SDPA reduction order — checked against
the flash-vs-composed tolerance.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Config.dropout (default 0). TinyTransformer gets a Cell<bool> training switch
(train()/eval()/with_training, default eval = safe) + a Cell<u64> step_seed bumped
once per training forward. forward_batched derives a per-layer block_seed (pure fn
of step_seed×layer) and block_forward derives two per-site seeds, inserting
ops::dropout at the attn and ffn sub-block outputs (before each residual). The
seed is a pure function of (step_seed, layer, site) so the checkpoint (T13)
recompute re-derives the same masks → grads stay exact. p=0 or eval → no dropout
node → graph bit-identical to pre-T18.
train_loop: model.train() per step (restored after eval flips to eval); eval_loss
runs model.eval(). bin/train: --dropout flag → cfg.dropout. Export/sampling run in
eval (default), so exported weights are dropout-free (xserv closed loop unaffected).
Model-level tests (dropout.rs): p=0 bit-identical to no-dropout (logits/loss/grads);
eval(p>0) == p=0 identity; train differs from eval + finite; recompute-with-dropout
grads match non-recompute (fp32 + bf16).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
ops::dropout(x,p,seed): fwd runs Tensor::dropout, caches the mask in the backward
closure, bwd pushes dx=d⊙mask. p==0 returns x.clone() (no node) so the default
graph is unchanged. Tests in autograd.rs: fixed-seed finite-diff grad-check (mask
held constant across the ± perturbation — dropout is a fixed elementwise linear
map of x); E[out]≈input + keep-rate≈1-p over a seed sweep; p=0 kernel identity.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
csrc/ops/dropout.cu: counter-based RNG (splitmix64 over seed^index) → fp32
uniform → Bernoulli(keep=1-p); fwd writes out=x⊙mask + an fp32 mask buffer
(per-element 1/(1-p) or 0); bwd applies the same mask (dx=d⊙mask). fp32 + bf16
activation variants (mask fp32 in both; uniform is dtype-independent so masks
match across precisions). Stateless → re-run with same seed = same mask (T13
recompute-safe). Registered in build.rs + FFI decls.
Tensor::dropout(p,seed)->(out,mask) and Tensor::dropout_backward(d,mask) wrap the
launches (contiguous F32/BF16, default stream, per-op sync via the kernels).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Counter-based (stateless) RNG → Bernoulli(keep=1-p) mask, inverted 1/(1-p)
scaling at train, identity at eval. New autodiff `dropout` op (fwd generates +
applies mask, bwd applies the SAME cached mask). Wired at the two residual-path
sites (attn / ffn outputs); attention-probs dropout deliberately skipped (fused
SDPA doesn't materialise probs). Documents the RNG choice, per-site deterministic
seed (so T13 recompute reproduces the same mask), train/eval switch, p=0
bit-identity, and the acceptance gates.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- grad_accum.rs: accum=N×B grads bit-close to a single N·B big batch;
accum_steps=1 bit-identical (max|Δ|==0) to no-accum; real train() loop
with accum tracks a big-batch baseline over 20 AdamW steps.
- ddp_correctness.rs: world=2 + accum=2 matches a single-GPU big batch of
the same effective size (loss + cross-rank + vs-baseline).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Accumulate grads over N micro-batches, then one AdamW step + zero_grad,
for an effective batch of N×micro at one micro-batch's activation cost.
Each micro-loss is scaled by 1/N before backward (the tape SUM-accumulates
the scaled grads) so the boundary grad equals a single step over an N×
batch. accum==1 skips the scale → bit-identical to the pre-T16 path.
DDP: the cross-rank all-reduce fires ONLY at the accumulation boundary
(intermediate micro-steps are local-only, no NCCL); the /world average is
orthogonal to the per-micro 1/N, so the boundary grad is the effective
global-batch mean. New --accum-steps flag in both train binaries; effective
batch is printed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fill in the design doc's measured results (grad-check, flash==composed,
PyTorch parity, peak mem -16%/-23%, tok/s tradeoff), add the T14 row to
evolution.md (算法/Infra) and the README build-journey table.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Match the trusted composed grad-check dims (seq=5<FA_TILE); the multi-tile
online-softmax path is gated by flash_bwd_matches_composed_bwd (seq=40),
sharper than finite-diff on the near-zero grads a long softmax produces.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
autograd: flash_attention_batched_bwd (dQ/dK/dV finite-diff, seq>tile)
+ flash_matches_composed_fwd. model/tests/flash.rs: flash==composed
on-vs-off (logits/loss/every param grad), fp32 + bf16. parity_dump:
XTRAIN_PARITY_FLASH dumps the flash path for the same parity.py oracle
(PyTorch SDPA parity at B>1). train + train_ddp get the --flash flag.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
ops::flash_attention autograd node (fwd caches O(N) logsumexp instead of
O(N²) probs; bwd via Tensor::flash_attention_backward). Model gets a
use_flash bool + with_flash(bool) builder; the SDPA core in attention()
picks ops::flash_attention vs ops::attention. flash threads through
block_forward so the recompute (T13) segment also runs flash. Default
off = composed path, graph unchanged.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
csrc/ops/flash_attention.cu: a single fused fwd kernel (one block per
query row, streams KV in tiles of 32, online softmax — running max/sum
+ rescaled V accumulator, causal mask inlined, never materializes the
[bh,S,S] scores) writing out[bh,S,hd] + the per-row logsumexp L (O(N),
saved for backward). flash-style bwd: recompute scores from Q/K/V + L,
collapse the softmax Jacobian with D[i]=ΣdO·O, dQ owned per row, dK/dV
atomicAdd across rows. Tensor::flash_attention / flash_attention_backward
wrap them (bf16 upcasts Q/K/V→f32 for the kernel, same fp32-softmax
policy as composed).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Design doc for the hand-written single fused flash-attention kernel:
online softmax tiled over KV, NEVER materializing the [bh,S,S] score
matrix; flash-style backward (recompute scores from saved logsumexp +
D=ΣdO·O, dQ/dK/dV). Opt-in --flash; composed T10 path stays default.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
v8 = capacity-axis A/B: freeze the v6/v7 2.255B FineWeb-edu subset, scale
dim768→dim1024 (core 127M→226M, +78%) via bf16 + T13 activation recompute.
8-GPU DDP, 2.36B tok (1.05 ep), ~129K tok/s (recompute tax), ~5h.
Result (same FineWeb val, v6/v7/v8 comparable): v6 3.0652 / v7 3.0149 /
v8 2.9801. Capacity helps — v8 (1.05ep) beats v6 at the same ~1ep by 0.085
AND beats v7 (smaller model, 1.45ep more old data) by 0.035 ⇒ v6/v7 were
partly capacity-limited, scaling capacity > repeating old data. But the gain
is only ~3% (same magnitude as the data-axis single-step lever), and v8's
val was still descending at the end (not saturated).
Meta-finding: every single-axis lever (data-volume v5/v7, breadth v6,
capacity v8) is now ~3%/lever ⇒ broad diminishing returns; to progress,
scale capacity AND data together (Chinchilla, reproduced at toy scale).
- docs/runs/08-v8-fineweb-edu-dim1024.md: full capacity experiment + v7-vs-v8 samples
- docs/runs/README.md: +v8 row, v9 proposal
- docs/evolution.md: +T13 infra row, +v8 scaling row, capacity-axis & diminishing-returns notes
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Design doc for per-block gradient checkpointing (KI-3): the no-tape forward +
recompute-on-backward design, the `checkpoint` primitive, per-block wrapping,
the exactness/correctness argument (same kernels + inputs → identical grads),
composition with bf16+DDP+batched, and the verification plan (on-vs-off grad
gate + memory/throughput before→after, dim1024-fits). Bench table left as TBD
to fill after the dash5 run.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Wrap each transformer block's forward in the checkpoint primitive when
recompute is enabled (Phase T13 / KI-3). To make the block forward a pure
segment fn (no `&self` borrow, so it can re-run in the backward closure),
extract the block body + its helpers (linear / norm_gamma / attention /
swiglu_mlp) into free functions parameterised by (cfg, compute_dtype) and add
`Block::block_params()` (the 11 leaves in the params() per-block order). The
non-recompute path calls `block_forward` directly — identical graph to before.
- `TinyTransformer::with_recompute(bool)` builder (opt-in; default off keeps the
unchanged tape / bit-identical numerics).
- `--recompute` flag wired into bin/train and bin/train_ddp (DDP: each rank
checkpoints independently).
Correctness gate: tests/recompute.rs builds two identical models (recompute
on/off), runs the same batched loss+backward, and asserts the forward logits,
the loss, and EVERY parameter grad match within tight fp tol — parameterised
over fp32 and bf16 (T12 composition).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Add `xtrain_autodiff::checkpoint::checkpoint(segment_fn, input, params)`, a
higher-order autograd node (à la torch.utils.checkpoint) for activation
recomputation (Phase T13 / KI-3):
- forward: run `segment_fn` on detached leaves so its internal ops are NOT
recorded on the outer tape; keep only the output value (the local sub-tape —
and thus the segment's intermediate activations — drops immediately). The
checkpoint node's parents are [input, ..params].
- backward: re-run `segment_fn` from the saved input + (unchanged) param values
into a fresh local tape, seed the recomputed output with the upstream grad,
backprop, then push the recovered input/param grads to the real parents. Local
tape drops at the end → recomputed activations freed.
Exact by construction (same deterministic kernels, same inputs) → grads match
the non-checkpointed path. Composes with bf16 (T12, same path on recompute) and
DDP (T8, per-rank).
Supporting change: `Var::backward_seeded(seed)` — backward from an explicit
non-scalar upstream grad (the segment output is generally not a scalar);
`backward()` is now the scalar wrapper that seeds ones.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
v7 = same arch as v4/v5/v6 (dim768/18L, bf16, 8-GPU DDP global 256),
trained the SAME 2.255B-token FineWeb-edu subset to 1.45 epoch (vs v6's
1.02), best FineWeb val 3.0149 (v6 3.0652). Exported + archived to
registry v7-fineweb-edu-dim768, serves in xserv (coherent expository
English, ~v6 quality).
Key finding: more epochs of the SAME subset gave only ~0.05 val drop and
the curve flattened (~step 44000) with no sampling quality gain → the
2.255B FineWeb subset is near its ceiling at dim768. Same class as v5's
TinyStories data-volume saturation: repeating old data has thin margins;
true further gains need FRESH shards (more diverse tokens), as v6's
corpus-swap (which raised the ceiling) showed.
Adds docs/runs/07-v7-*.md; updates docs/runs/README.md (+v7 row, intro
saturation note, v8 proposal) and docs/evolution.md (+v7 row, dataset-axis
ceiling note).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
